We’re Calling It: Quince’s Leather Boots Are the ‘Comfiest’ Shoe of the Season, and 75-Year-Old Shoppers Agree

Finding black booties that go with anything sounds easy enough, but finally landing on a pair that’s comfortable and an affordable investment piece is often exhausting. But we found a style at Quince (obviously) that achieves all of those requirements and more. 

The Quince Italian Leather Stretch Sock Bootie “looks expensive,” according to several shoppers, and given its luxe materials, cushioned insoles, and dozens of reviews that note how “super comfortable” it is, we’re sold that this pair is worth your attention. 

Quince Italian Leather Stretch Sock Bootie

The “It boot” of the season is made from 100 percent Italian sheep leather in both the upper and the lining. It’s clear from the construction that blending style with comfort was an important part of the design. An ortholite insole for extra cushioning and arch support was also added since these are specifically made for ease of wear. 

The leather outsole and low, 2-inch heel have traction for added stability as well. That’s something that made a 75-year-old shopper call these boots “worth every penny.” They said the boots are “comfortable, beautiful,” and clearly “well-made.” The reviewer also added that the heel is “high enough” to feel dressy but “low enough to be safe and comfortable.” Another person who shared that they have a “hard time” wearing a low heel called this pair “extremely comfortable.”

Quince Italian Leather Stretch Sock Bootie

Many shoppers also complimented the leather outer that’s stretchy, meaning anyone is able to find their own custom fit. A customer with plantar fasciitis said they have “hard-to-fit feet” with narrow heels and wider toes but noted the “soft leather” of the boots “quickly stretched to fit [their] feet.” They added the shoes are “surprisingly comfortable,” given their condition, too. A few happy shoppers agreed the boots felt good “right out of the box,” noting that there is “no break-in period needed.”

If you’re looking for a comfortable yet sophisticated pair of wear-with-everything boots, grab the Quince Italian Leather Stretch Sock Bootie in black, merlot, or bone. And take a look below at more boot options for the season from Quince. 

Eco Knit Heeled Bootie

Suede Chelsea Boot

Italian Leather Riding Boots

Italian Leather Tall Kitten Heel Boots