Dancing with the Stars Pro Witney Carson and Husband Carson McAllister Celebrate 10 Years of Marriage: ‘Journey of a Lifetime’

Dancing with the Stars‘ Witney Carson is celebrating a decade of marriage.

The dance pro, 32, married her high school sweetheart, Carson McAllister, in Salt Lake City on New Year’s Day in 2016, and in honor of their 10th wedding anniversary, the pair posted heartfelt Instagram tributes dedicated to one another.

“Celebrating a decade with you @carson.mcallister and ringing in the new year with our two beautiful boys 🥹🤍,” Carson began her post on Wednesday, Dec. 31, referring to the couple’s sons, Kevin Leo, who turns 5 on Jan. 3, and Jet, 2.

The DWTS season 34 champion continued, “I truly don’t know how life could get better than this, but I’m excited to see what’s next for our little family. Here’s to 2026! ✨.”

In the Instagram Reel, which was set to the tune “Weathervane” by Hunter Metts, Carson and McAllister danced together in front of a glistening body of water as the sun set. Their children then joined them, and the family shared a big group hug before admiring the ombré sky together.

In his own post featuring photos of the family of four in matching black outfits, McAllister shared that his love for his wife “keeps growing” over the years.

“10 years and my love for you keeps growing @witneycarson,” he wrote. “Marrying you started the journey of a lifetime. So much has happened and you’ve been by my side through it all making me smile, laugh, and be a better person. 2025 will be one to remember.”

“I can’t wait for all our adventures in 2026 and I need you by my side through all of it!” he added. “I love you Witney Carson!”

Speaking to PEOPLE in 2016 about her nuptials, Carson gushed that her lace long-sleeved wedding dress, which was handmade by Rivini designer Rita Vinieris, was so “beautiful” and “perfect” that she “didn’t want to take it off.”

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

As for her bridesmaids, which included fellow pro dancers Emma Slater, Lindsay Arnold, Brittany Cherry and Jenna Johnson, Carson chose Amsale dresses in a taupe color that fit in with the “winter wonderland” feel of her New Year’s Day ceremony.

“The dresses were all the same color, but they were all very different,” Carson said. “It meant so much for them to be there. I wanted the dresses to match their unique personalities.”