Dakota Johnson, Anne Hathaway, and More Stars Agree: Loafers Are the Timeless Fall Shoe You Can Wear So Many Ways

Lately, there’s a shoe that I can’t stop thinking about (or seeing). It’s the classic loafer, and it’s also noticeably favored by some of the most well-dressed celebrities on my radar. 

From Dakota Johnson and Jane Fonda to Brittany Snow and Anne Hathaway, each leading lady uniquely styled the timeless shoe, whether accompanied by a dressy look or a low-key ensemble. I’ve even spotted fictional characters opting for this shoe, like Lola Tung’s Belly from The Summer I Turned Pretty, who threw on a brown pair with a shift dress and jean jacket. 

It was obvious what I had to do next: I tracked down 10 pairs of loafers inspired by these celeb-worn styles from Nordstrom, Target, Amazon, and more stores. Shop my picks from $30. 

Loafers Inspired By Celebrities

Sam Edelman Loraine Bit Loafer

If you’ve ever wondered what movie stars like Dakota Johnson wear to the grocery store, allow me to give you the insight —  it’s a relaxed gray T-shirt, straight-leg jeans, and a pair of well-worn loafers. I’m a fan of the simplicity of this look, which fueled my search to find a lookalike for her shoes. 

These Sam Edelman loafers showcase similar gold hardware across the upper, as well as a narrower toe. They also have a cushioned footbed, which helps if you’re also planning a Johnson-esque run to Erewhon. 

Blondo Waterproof Penny Loafer

At 87 years old, Jane Fonda is as stylish and elegant as ever. Earlier this year, she paired her eggplant-colored suit with cheetah-print loafers at the 2025 California Conference for Women, using her slip-ons as a statement piece. One such pair that embodies the same playfulness as hers is this waterproof style by Blondo. Along with the bold print, the memory-foam footbed and a thick lug bottom are standouts, as they help you stay steady on uneven and slippery surfaces.

Dream Pairs Penny Loafers

Since The Devil Wears Prada 2 has begun filming, the PEOPLE shopping team has been keeping close tabs on the cast’s on-set looks. In doing so, I spotted yet another pair of sleek loafers on Anne Hathaway herself. Along with an olive-hued midi skirt and crisp white button-down, her character Andy Sachs slipped into a pair of black loafers. 

There’s no telling how expensive the wardrobe budget is on the film, but this lookalike style is just $30 right now. “I wore them for 10 hours straight at work and had zero blisters,” one Amazon shopper wrote.

Keep scrolling to peruse more celeb-inspired loafers, including a platform pair similar to the ones Brittany Snow previously wore and a brown style from Everlane that reminds me of Lola Tung’s. 

Quince Italian Leather Lug Sole Loafer

Everlane The Modern Loafer

Journee Collection Jessamy Lug Loafer

Gap Vegan Suede Loafers

Banana Republic Factory Leather Loafer

Vionic Cleo Loafer

Journee Lacie Slip-On Loafers